2019

Ten years ago, this would have been an average song.. But the song is a good showcase of how we are missing melody today.. And even Shreya, though the male singer introduced later is succesful in reducing the impact.. -Pavan

Shreya Ghosal excels in this wonderful melody. -Naresh

A new find for me, Shreya steals the show with the vocals, and Sunjoy's soundscape sets for a very ambient listen, but the song went downhill for me after the male vocals by him pitch in. Seema Saini's lyrics are imaginative, enjoyed them. -Rujul

ऐसा जान पड़ता है कि इसे धुन पर बोल बिठाकर बनाया गया है. इसी वजह से गाने के आख़िर में आते-आते बोल कमज़ोर होते महसूस हुए. इस तरह के गाने श्रेया पहले भी गाती आई हैं. गीत की शुरुआत अच्छी थी, लेकिन गहराई या बांधे रखने का तिलिस्म कम. गीत दो हिस्सों में बाँटा गया है, शुरूआती हिस्सा जो श्रेया के हिस्से आया उसमें तबला और दूसरे इंस्ट्रूमेंट सुनाई दिए, लेकिन जैसे ही मेल वॉइस आती है गीत का अरेंजमेंट काफ़ी वेस्टर्न बन जाता है. जो ताल (कहरवा ?) इस्तेमाल की गई वो भी सुनने वालों के लिए कोई सरप्राइज़ ऐलीमेंट नहीं रोक सकी. -विकास

Shreya is definitely become more nasal,. -Hemendra

Reminiscent, in a good way, of some of the semi-classical numbers that Shantanu Moitra used to compose. -Sankhayan

Beautiful melody with the Queen on vocals, what more do you want? -DM

Disjointed lyrics which don’t flow from one line to another. I can see why the music composer has struggled in the song. Even Shreya couldn’t lift it up. -Akanksha

The flute and the strings remind you of a calm night where the lovers serenade each other, using the moon as the placeholder as their beloved. As the sublime Shreya Goshal starts singing, subtle tablas and guitars kick in, making the listener sway in time to the beat. The lyrics are so visceral and visual that I can imagine two lovers on the opposite side of the river, eagerly anticipating the crossing to happen as gentle snows fall "Phir mile wo waadiyan
Aur tu saath hai
Phir milenge hum
Phir giregi barf". The only weakness is Sunjoy Bose's singing. -Krithikaa

Lyrics often awkward; male singer could be better. -Ashok

Deducted 1 point on singing for the male voice. Shreya is good but there's nothing here to recommend repeat listening. -Subrat

Nice tune and even Shreya doesn't tinny. Sujnoy Bose complements her well. -Ketan

if you listen to this one right after haay re farebi, it seems like a continuation of the previous song :) musically. -Neha

Pretty good for most part, but takes a drastic dive once the male singer kicks in. Shreya, however, sounds very good. The lyrics appear to be all over the place. -Aditya

Lovely use of acoustic guitar and the flute. I had never heard of this composer before. -Sunil

What a refreshing song in rest of the pack (singing points only for Shreya, not for the male singer). -Abhay