काहे मुस्काये रे (भवई) kaahe muskaaye re (Bhavai) |
2.27
|
शब्बीर अहमद | शब्बीर अहमद | श्रेया घोषाल | |
2.23 | 1.86 | 2.77 | |
Shabbir Ahmed | Shabbir Ahmed | Shreya Ghoshal |
Shabbir Ahmed seemed to have been inspired by SLB-Bhansali's school of music here. Didn't find the tune to be very engaging. He fares much better as a lyricist. -Anish
The Gujarati garba rhythm invokes Bhansali-esq ambiance and mood. Shreya Ghoshal sounds fantastic, as usual. -Vishal
Flute entry reminiscent of something Ilaiyaraja...Shreya delivers as expected. Instruments tasteful, sound production has come such a long way in the 21st century. -Sanjeev
Repeat of overused old metaphors in the lyrics. Shreya does a valiant job singing superbly, but cannot rescue the song. -UVR
Shreya at her precious worst. Sounds like something that escaped from a Bhansali film. -Shalini
Nice use of clapping interspersed with melody. -Sumi
Reminder of 90s style dandiya songs, but Shreya’s voice makes it sound modern. -Suanshu
Shreya Ghoshal is the only good part about this song. -Aman
Shreya Ghosal elevates the song to some extent but that's that. -Sukanya
Attn: Navratri orchestras. -Nishant
Back to 2021 Puraskaar home
Vinay P Jain. Feedback to giitaayan at gmail dot com. February 2022.