पिया समाए (मुल्क) piyaa samaae (Mulk) |
2.18
|
अनुराग सैकिया | शकील आज़मी | शफ़क़त अमानत अली, अर्शद हुसैन | |
2.23 | 2.43 | 2.50 | |
Anurag Saikia | Shakeel Azmi | Shafqat Amanat Ali, Arshad Hussain |
Shafqat's soothing vocals are welcome. Refreshing to hear a lovely semi-classical and qawaali genre after a long time. -Sowmya
Generic sufi song with Qawwali elements. -DM
It's not a good sign when the chorus sounds better than one of the lead singers. Never heard the word jhajhat' in a Sufi qawalli before this. -Ketan
Wish we had more of these than an occasional number sometimes. -Nishant
I have a special affection for songs in Roopak taal. -Meera
There's a limit to the supposed appeal of the "raw, untrained" voice, the first voice is just grating - Shafqat is a breath of fresh air; Something "been there, done that" about the song and idiom...in fact it reminds me a lot of "Bismillah" featured in Coke Studio - 7-beat rhythm, Des/Tilak-Kamod influence, even the key of G. -Sanjeev
A decent listen, yet lacks intensity and innovation in treatment, fails to reach a high. -Pavan
Haven't heard Shafqat Amanat Ali sing in a very long time, and I am glad to see him return to Bollywood playback. (Is it a return or have I just not noticed his songs?) Reminiscent of Piya haji ali at times, not just because of the genre but also in melody. Sufi/ qawwali songs in Hindi films are starting to get pretty formulaic, aaj kal. -Megha
Sounds like a song composed for Shafaqat to show his singing prowess. Unmemorable. -Hemendra
Great to see such compositions being made in this era. -Arun
Soulful singing by both vocalists. Beautiful lyrics-"koi hara koi gerua baataye"! -Sunil
OK, but too long. -Ashok
2018 पुरस्कार मुखपृष्ठ पर वापस - Back to 2018 Puraskaar home
विनय प्र जैन. प्रतिक्रियाएँ giitaayan at gmail dot com पर भेजें. फरवरी 2019.