I really like Rajshekhar's conversational lyrics. Only wish the song wasn't so stuck to a meter & format. -Meera

This song feels like it had the potential to be a truly great song, but it’s creators were in too much of a hurry to finish the song and get it to the recording room, so they half-assed it in all departments. -UVR

Sweet but ultimately boring!. -Arun Verma

Atif Aslam's weak voice combined with the soaring music obscure the melody and the lyrics. -Shalini Razdan

Ever since he debuted with Itne Dafe (Yun Hi) in Tanu Weds Manu, lyricist Raj Shekhar has demonstrated a way with words that makes his lyrics sound non-mainstream and interesting. And so it is with Jaane De. Atif Aslam - haters notwithstanding - delivers another ear candy of a song. -Param

Atif sounds better than expected...how much thanks to the effects? -Sanjeev

ये गाना इस बरस का हासिल है। इस बरस जिन गानों को साथ लेकर आगे बढ़ना चाहूंगा-- उनमें से ये गाना पहला होगा। एक ऐसे अहसास को राज शेखर ने बोल दिए जिसे अलफाज में उतारना बेहद मुश्किल है। जगजाहिर है कि ये गीत मुझे बहुत बहुत प्रिय है। ये गाना आँख से टपकते टपकते रूक गया आंसू है। -Yunus

Pure poetry rendered into a affectionate, hummable melody. -Anup

Nothing outstanding, and yet not much to complain about either. -Megha

Jaane de, featuring Atif Aslam, is a serene melody befitting Atif’s dreamy voice. -Karthik