Simple. Poetic. And heartfelt. This song captures not only the romantic mood of the situation but also stays with you for a long time after it is over. A welcome return by Anu Malik and sung passionately and in equally beautiful fashion by both Monali Thakur and Papon. It is difficult to pick one version over the other. -Vikas

It's not easy to accept this as an Anu Malik tune. He has not only composed a nice tune, Varun Grover's words fit in it very beautifully. Monali puts her heart into it, and it shows in the final product. The last time I remember her doing this is with "Sanwaar Loon" from Lootera (2013). -UVR

Anu Malik's lovely music leaves a lingering effect. -Shivani

Anu Malik's best effort in last decade by miles.. Beautiful arrangement. -Pavan

Easily the song of the year for me. Everything about this is top-notch. -Aditya

This sounds so much better than the male version. Controlled singing, no overemoting. -Ketan

Has an old world charm. -Vinayakam

Anu Malik couldn’t have asked for a better comeback. His composition is musically rich seamlessly moving from one raaga to another. He effectively employs Naveen Kumar’s flute and Omkar Dhumal’s Shehnai especially during the interludes. The song is beautifully worded by Varun Grover. A repetition of Moh-Moh, Toh-Toh gives it a journey like feel. Heart skips when Monali sings तू होगा ज़रा पागल, तूने मुझको है चुना. Her singing is effortless.
तू दिन सा है, मैं रात.. आना दोनों.. मिल जाए शामों की तरह. Absolutely love the words. -Mihir M

Monali is coming forward with great songs. I don't like her song quality and singing these days who knows with technology being what it is. a little more attention to her pronunciation would be nice!. -Neha

What do we have here? An Anu Malik winner? To give the devil his due, it is a beautiful composition - shehnai, flute and the arrangement all in order; the pauses in place and the certain sense of quietude. The singing is good with Monali Thakur giving it the right emotion (unlike her Sawaar Loon in the past). -Subrat

Is it me only me who thinks that 'girahaa' does not sit naturally in that mukh.daa and also that Bollywood have abandoned any effort at rhyming as well, so 'barase' follows 'ulajhe' and 'sulajhe'. The song works fine overall, because of Monali's singing and a fine tune. Reminds one of MM Kreem rather than Anu in his heyday. -Vibhendu

Some places have a nice melodic structure. -Abhay

Like this reprise version better than the male one. Monali impresses the listener and so does Anu Malik. -Sowmya

"तू होगा ज़रा पागल, तूने मुझको है चुना" वरुण की लिखी यह पंक्तियाँ सुनते हुए मुझे रे की महानगर का क्लाईमैक्स याद आया था। किसी रचनात्मक अभिव्यक्ति की इससे बड़ी तारीफ़ मेरे पास नहीं। -मिहिर पं.

Sincere tune and singing. -Armeen

Neat song. I slightly preferred the female version. -Ashok