Beyond the already fabulous soundtrack of Aisha, this song emerges, albeit after we've gorged on the more massy tracks, as the soundtrack's best! -Karthik

 

 

The violin refrain at the beginning and elsewhere is the best part about the song , holds it well. 'kaliyaa.N murajhaa gaye?'- how did Javed Akhtar let that pass, or does it go with the prevailing laissez-faire attitude in these matters? -Vibhendu

 

Love this song. Lovely jazz/club arrangement. Cannot beat *real drums*! Amazing violin leads and counters. Splendid guitar (lead and rhythm both). Singer's is the perfect voice for this song. -Pranav

 

100 points for the violins and drums - beautiful tango between the two. -Shashi

 

The cello is haunting and the singing good and the combination makes for a very nice listening experience indeed. Proper Urdu talaffuz no longer seems to be a pre-requisite for singers :-( and I've chosen to ignore the singer's mispronunciations even though it pains my poor heart so! -UVR

 

I liked that the song conveys melancholy sans melodrama. -Shalini

 

The simplicity of the song captured my attention. Beautifully laid out with the violin piece streaming back and forth and nice chords. -Sowmya

 

Nice use of the violin. -Gajendra