अब जाने की ज़िद न करो ab jaane kii zid na karo |
2.35
|
सार्थक कल्याणी, सत्यांश रजत | शाश्वत सचदेव | सार्थक कल्याणी, सत्यांश रजत | |
2.26 | 2.08 | 2.49 | |
Sarthak Kalyani, Satyansh Rajat | Shashwat Sachdev | Sarthak Kalyani, Satyansh Rajat |
A good basic melody: you can't go wrong with Yaman-based tunes. The lyrics are pleasant, but average. That said, the final outcome is quite middling. There is just too much stuffed into it. Overly earnest singing, so-so lyrics and ... that sargam portion UGGGGHHHH! I really did find the needless interjection of the out-of-breath sargam segments utterly insufferable. Ignoring my personal distaste for those parts, I still don't see this song lasting in public imagination beyond a year, or two at the most. -UVR
Nice composition, but that totally unexpected simper threw me off. -Vishal
Good effort, though I must say - Yaman has been a favourite of artistes and one needs to be more innovative and go beyond the regular chalan now. This treatment is slightly passe. -Meera
This zid is also yaman based. Could have been orchestrated better. -Nishant
Interesting take from the famous song. -Vaishali
Riveting rendition. -Sukanya
Such a cool twist to the classic! -Aman
Electronic music is overbearing along with decent singing, which gets off-key towards the end. -Suanshu
Gave a zero for lyrics because I need more than the repetition of the line "ab jaane ki zid na karo". -Shalini
Liked the way Sarthak Kalyani rendered the song. The techno driven arrangements create a certain mood. -Anish
Fresh but immature. Lost opportunity. -Arun
Lazy attempt at a takeoff on the original "Jaane Ki Zid Na Karo". Voice is too light and airy, and singing is too loosy-goosey. -Sanjeev
Back to 2021 Puraskaar home
Vinay P Jain. Feedback to giitaayan at gmail dot com. February 2022.