RMIM Puraskaar


एक नदी थी (मिर्ज़्या)
ek nadii thii (Mirzya)

शंकर-अहसान-लॉय गुलज़ार नूराँ सिस्टर्स, के मोहन  
3.03  3.66  3.14   
Shankar-Ehsaan-Loy Gulzar Nooran Sisters, K Mohan  
Jury comments

Powerful voices of Nooran sisters, K. Mohan, and chorus along with excellent arrangement with guitars make this song transcendent. -Vaishali

Wonderful imagery by Gulzar. -Naresh

Song and poem blur lines here. Short for the length of a song, but deep like a river itself. Nooran sisters in jugalbandi with K Mohan, both accompanied by choir led by Shankar Minimal yet exquisite arrangement. -Anup

It's not usual to hear a harmony-oriented song, so this stood out. Pity it was such a small piece. -Ramanand

opens to a lovely A cappella featuring Nooran Sisters and Agnee’s Mohan when the guitars kick-in, to take the flow to a new high, with the lead vocals and the chorus staying amazingly on top. -Karthik

Amazing lyrics. Love the guitar. -Shalini

More than anything else, interesting. Given the title, I expected better. -Ashok

The words are perfect. The whole issue is talked about in a beautiful analogy. -Harshit

loved this song when hearing for this exercise. Had heard mirzya before but not paid much attention to this song. Love the singing by Nooran sisters and the overall effect of the minimal music accompanied. -Neha

Simply beautiful and touches at so many levels. Again, scores high in all departments though here the lyrics score much higher - they resonate and have an emotional appeal for almost any woman and Gulzar's magical touch is felt more than it usually is in his newer lyrics... -Archana

I can listen to Nooran sisters for a long time. Here the folk elements are uniformly nice but the guitars bring an element of novelty and subversiveness that's least expected. -Subrat

Now this is getting repetitive. -Abhay

Ends too soon! -Aditya

नोट: गानों को अंक केवल श्रेष्ठता के लिए दिए गए हैं. यानी एक आम गाने को कोई अंक नहीं दिया गया. केवल औसत से बेहतर प्रदर्शन के लिए अंक हैं. हर श्रेणी में अधिकतम अंक 5 हैं.
Note: The ratings/scores are on a positive-only scale. This means that an average performance gets a zero and the ratings go up from there. Maximum 5 marks per category.

गीत सूची पर वापस | Back to list of songs

comments powered by Disqus

2016 पुरस्कार मुखपृष्ठ पर वापस - Back to 2016 Puraskaar home

विनय प्र जैन. प्रतिक्रियाएँ giitaayan at gmail dot com पर भेजें. फरवरी 2017.