RMIM Puraskaar


अच्छी सूरत पे (जाँनिसार)
achchhii suurat pe (Jaanisaar)

मुज़फ़्फ़र अली दाग़ देहलवी श्रेया घोषाल  
2.05  5.00  2.32   
Muzaffar Ali Daagh Dehalvi Shreya Ghoshal  
Jury comments

Long time no see for a mujra based song. And on top of that it is a good composition, with authentic arrangements. -Ketan

Discernibly Des and 'Desi'... a good change. -Armeen

Who is this Dagh Dehlvi, some new lyricist? He writes very well indeed! What excellent Urdu vocabulary he uses! (This is how I imagine some conversations going these days). BTW, I should explain the '1' rating for the singing: I don't think Shreya does a good job with these tawaaif-type songs. She tries too hard to inject the necessary 'baazaarupan' into her voice and comes off too earnest. "kambaKht Ghazal bhi gaati hai to lagta hai bhajan gaa rahi hai". -UVR

Umarao Jaan redux? But this is no Khayyam soundtrack. It is all sarangi, shehnai, tabla and one major Sitar interlude without any soul. Shreya Ghosal sings well but there's no real material to work on. -Subrat

Could be better; too long, but stil doesn't conclude well. -Ashok

Shreya's rendition is goose bumpy. The music is above average. -Sowmya

Dagh's words are fantastic and frankly the last misra of the maqta simply did me in… "vahi daanaa hai kahaa jisne na maanaa dil ka". -Archana

Old-world charm. So refreshing to hear traditional instruments and old poetry in 2015. -Aditya

नोट: गानों को अंक केवल श्रेष्ठता के लिए दिए गए हैं. यानी एक आम गाने को कोई अंक नहीं दिया गया. केवल औसत से बेहतर प्रदर्शन के लिए अंक दिए गए हैं. हर श्रेणी में अधिकतम अंक 5 हैं.
Note: The ratings/scores are on a positive-only scale. This means that an average performance gets a zero and the ratings go up from there. Maximum 5 marks per category.

गीत सूची पर वापस | Back to list of songs

comments powered by Disqus

2015 पुरस्कार मुखपृष्ठ पर वापस - Back to 2015 Puraskaar home

विनय प्र जैन. प्रतिक्रियाएँ giitaayan at gmail dot com पर भेजें. जनवरी 2015.